Teacher Professional Development

Critical Friend in Education and How to be a Good Critical Friend

Critical Friend in Education and How to be a Good Critical Friend

Critical friend meaning

A “critical friend” in education refers to a supportive and constructive relationship between two teachers or professionals who work together to improve teaching and learning. This concept is rooted in the idea that teachers can benefit from feedback and input from their peers to enhance their practice. The critical friend serves as a trusted colleague who offers feedback, asks probing questions, and provides suggestions for improvement in a respectful and non-judgmental manner.

New Teacher Lesson Observation/ Supervisory Requirement in Ghana 2024

Here are some key aspects of the critical friend concept in education:

  1. Supportive Feedback: Critical friends provide constructive feedback on each other’s teaching methods, curriculum development, and classroom management. They focus on strengths as well as areas that need improvement.
  2. Objective Perspective: Critical friends are typically not in a supervisory or evaluative role, which allows them to offer a more objective perspective. This can help teachers feel more comfortable sharing their challenges and seeking help.
  3. Collaborative Problem Solving: They engage in collaborative problem-solving, helping each other find solutions to educational challenges. This can include brainstorming ideas, suggesting resources, or sharing best practices.
  4. Professional Growth: The primary goal of the critical friend relationship is to support professional growth and development. teachers can use this feedback to enhance their teaching skills and improve student outcomes.
  5. Confidentiality and Trust: A critical friend relationship relies on trust and confidentiality. teachers should feel safe sharing their concerns and challenges without fear of judgment or negative consequences.
  6. Reflective Practice: Critical friends often encourage reflective practice, where teachers think deeply about their teaching methods, classroom strategies, and the impact on student learning.
  7. Peer Learning Community: In some cases, critical friend relationships extend to form a broader peer learning community where teachers come together to share experiences, resources, and expertise.


Importance of critical friend in education

The importance of a critical friend in education cannot be overstated. Having a trusted colleague or mentor who serves as a critical friend provides several valuable benefits to fascilitators, students, and the education system as a whole:

Professional Growth

Quality Assurance; By having a critical friend review and assess their teaching methods, teachers can ensure the quality of education they provide to students. This contributes to better learning outcomes and overall educational excellence.

Fresh Perspectives: Critical friends often bring fresh perspectives and new ideas to the table. They can challenge established practices and encourage teachers to innovate in their teaching methods, which can lead to more engaging and effective instruction.

Accountability: Knowing that a critical friend is there to provide feedback can encourage teachers to be more accountable for their actions and decisions. This accountability can lead to increased diligence and dedication to their profession.

Reflection: Critical friends encourage teachers to engage in reflective practice. This involves thinking deeply about their teaching methods, the impact on students, and how to improve. Regular reflection is essential for effective teaching.

Emotional Support: Teaching can be a challenging profession, and teachers often face stress and burnout. A critical friend can provide emotional support, offering a listening ear and advice to help teachers cope with challenges.

Collaboration: The relationship with a critical friend promotes collaboration among teachers. This collaboration can extend to sharing resources, co-planning lessons, and working together to address common educational issues.

Student Benefit: Ultimately, the primary beneficiaries of the critical friend relationship are the students. When teachers receive feedback and support to improve their teaching, students have access to better-quality education and are more likely to succeed academically.

Professional Community: Critical friends contribute to the formation of a professional community within the education field. This community fosters a culture of continuous improvement and shared learning.

Retention and Job Satisfaction: teacherss who have a critical friend are often more satisfied in their roles and less likely to leave the profession. The support and growth opportunities offered by a critical friend can contribute to teacher retention.

Critical friend can cover for you and would be there for you as you have to run certain errands

How to become a good critical friend

Becoming a good critical friend requires a combination of skills, qualities, and approaches that focus on providing constructive feedback, offering support, and fostering productive relationships. Here are some steps and tips to become an effective critical friend:

Build Trust: Trust is the foundation of any critical friend relationship. Ensure that the individual or team you are assisting feels comfortable sharing their challenges, concerns, and goals with you. Confidentiality is crucial in building trust.

Active Listening: Practice active listening skills to fully understand the issues and perspectives of the person or group you’re supporting. Ask clarifying questions to delve deeper into their challenges and goals.

Empathy: Show empathy and understanding towards the challenges and pressures the individual or team is facing. Demonstrating empathy can help create a safe and supportive environment.

Constructive Feedback: Offer feedback in a constructive and non-judgmental manner. Focus on specific behaviors, actions, or outcomes rather than making it personal. Use “I” statements to express your observations and suggestions.

Balanced Perspective: Provide a balanced perspective that includes both positive feedback and areas for improvement. Acknowledge the strengths and achievements while also addressing areas that need attention.

Socratic Questioning: Use Socratic questioning techniques to encourage critical thinking. Ask open-ended questions that prompt reflection and deeper analysis.

Be Specific: When offering feedback or suggestions, be specific and provide examples whenever possible. This makes it easier for the individual or team to understand and act upon your recommendations.

Respect Autonomy: Respect the autonomy of the individual or team you are assisting. Your role is to offer guidance, not to make decisions for them. Support their decision-making process even if it differs from your perspective.

Regular Communication: Maintain open and regular communication with the person or group you’re assisting. Check in on their progress, offer assistance when needed, and be accessible for discussions.

Continuous Learning: Stay informed and up-to-date in relevant areas to provide valuable insights and advice. Continuously improve your own knowledge and skills to be a better critical friend.

Cultural Sensitivity: Be culturally sensitive and aware of diversity. Different individuals and groups may have unique cultural backgrounds, values, and perspectives that should be considered in your interactions.

Reflect on Your Role: Periodically reflect on your own role as a critical friend. Evaluate your effectiveness, gather feedback from the person or team you’re assisting, and make adjustments as needed.

Conflict Resolution: Be prepared to address conflicts or disagreements that may arise in a constructive and respectful manner. Conflict can be an opportunity for growth and improved understanding.

Maintain Boundaries: Understand the boundaries of your role as a critical friend. While you offer support and advice, avoid becoming overly involved or taking on responsibilities that are not within your scope.

Celebrate Success: Celebrate achievements and milestones together. Acknowledging progress and success can be motivating and reinforce a positive working relationship.

What You Must Never do as a Critical Friend in Education

As a critical friend in education, it’s essential to maintain a supportive, respectful, and constructive approach to your role. To ensure that you are effective and helpful in this capacity, there are several things you must never do:

Don’t Be Judgmental: Avoid passing judgment or making harsh criticisms. Your role is to provide constructive feedback and support, not to criticize or demean the individual or their work.

Don’t Violate Confidentiality: Never breach the trust and confidentiality of the person or team you are assisting. Keep all discussions, concerns, and sensitive information confidential.

Don’t Impose Solutions: Resist the urge to impose your own solutions or ideas. Your role is to guide and facilitate the individual’s or team’s problem-solving process, not to dictate outcomes.

Don’t Overstep Boundaries: Respect the boundaries of your role as a critical friend. Avoid becoming overly involved in the decision-making process or taking on responsibilities that are not within your scope.

Don’t Offer Unsolicited Feedback: Always seek permission before offering feedback or advice. Don’t provide unsolicited feedback, as it may come across as intrusive or unwelcome.

Don’t Neglect Empathy: Avoid being overly critical or harsh in your feedback. Maintain empathy and understanding towards the challenges and pressures the individual or team is facing.

Don’t Assume Expertise: While you may have expertise in certain areas, don’t assume that you know better than the person you are assisting. Recognize that they are the experts in their context and experiences.

Don’t Disregard Cultural Sensitivity: Be culturally sensitive and aware of diversity. Avoid making assumptions based on cultural or personal biases.

Don’t Foster Dependency: Encourage independence and self-reliance in the individuals or teams you are assisting. Avoid creating a dependency on your guidance or advice.

Don’t Be Inflexible: Be open to adapting your approach based on the needs and preferences of the person or team you are working with. Avoid rigidly sticking to your own methods or ideas.

Don’t Ignore Emotional Well-being: Pay attention to the emotional well-being of the individuals you are assisting. If they are experiencing emotional distress, don’t dismiss it; offer support or refer them to appropriate resources.

Don’t Neglect Positive Feedback: While constructive criticism is essential, don’t neglect positive feedback. Acknowledge and celebrate achievements and strengths as well.

Don’t Disregard Individual Goals: Respect the individual’s or team’s goals and priorities. Don’t push your own agenda or goals onto them.

Don’t Force Change: Avoid pressuring individuals or teams to make changes that they are not ready for or comfortable with. Change should be driven by their own motivation and readiness.

Don’t Neglect Self-Reflection: As a critical friend, periodically reflect on your own effectiveness and approach. Be open to feedback from the individuals you are assisting and continuously strive to improve your role.

Being a critical friend in education requires a delicate balance of providing constructive feedback, support, and guidance while respecting boundaries and maintaining a positive, empathetic, and non-judgmental attitude. Avoiding the above-mentioned actions will help you maintain the integrity and effectiveness of your role as a critical friend.


New PLC Topics for Teachers in Ghana and NTS 2024

Here are some challenges of critical friendship in education

While critical friendships in education can be highly beneficial, they also come with their fair share of challenges. It’s essential to be aware of these challenges and take proactive steps to address them to ensure the relationship remains constructive and productive.

Here are some common challenges of critical friendships in education:

Establishing Trust: Building trust can be a challenge, especially if the individuals involved are not already well-acquainted. It takes time to develop the level of trust required for open and honest communication.

Maintaining Confidentiality: Ensuring confidentiality is crucial, but it can be challenging, especially when discussing sensitive topics. Participants must be mindful of keeping discussions private.

Balancing Roles: Striking the right balance between offering constructive criticism and maintaining a supportive, non-judgmental stance can be challenging. Participants may struggle with knowing when to push for improvement and when to provide emotional support.

Cultural and Personal Differences: Participants in a critical friendship may come from diverse cultural backgrounds and have different personal values and beliefs. These differences can sometimes lead to misunderstandings or miscommunications.

Managing Emotions: When discussing professional challenges and receiving feedback, emotions can run high. Participants must learn to manage their emotions and maintain a professional demeanor.

Availability and Commitment: Finding time for regular meetings and maintaining a consistent level of commitment to the critical friendship can be challenging, especially when both participants have busy schedules.

Overcoming Defensiveness: It’s common for individuals to become defensive when receiving critical feedback, even when it’s well-intentioned. Helping each other overcome defensiveness is an ongoing challenge.

Handling Conflict: Disagreements or conflicts may arise within the critical friendship. Knowing how to address and resolve these conflicts constructively is essential to maintaining the relationship’s effectiveness.

Power Dynamics: In some cases, there may be power imbalances between the individuals involved in the critical friendship. This can complicate the relationship, as the less powerful individual may hesitate to provide honest feedback to the more powerful one.

Resistance to Change: Implementing changes based on feedback can be difficult, and individuals may resist making adjustments to their practices, even when they recognize the need for improvement.

Alignment of Goals: Ensuring that both participants share common goals and objectives for the critical friendship can be challenging. Misalignment can lead to frustration and unproductive interactions.

Maintaining Consistency: Critical friendships require ongoing attention and effort. Sustaining the relationship and keeping the momentum going can be challenging over the long term.

Assessing Impact: Measuring the impact of the critical friendship on professional growth and development can be challenging. It may be difficult to determine whether the feedback and support provided have led to positive changes in practice.

To address these challenges,

It’s crucial for participants in a critical friendship to establish clear expectations,

communicate openly, and continuously work on improving their communication and interpersonal skills.

Additionally, seeking guidance or training in mentorship and coaching techniques can be beneficial for both parties.

Ultimately, overcoming these challenges can lead to a more effective and mutually beneficial critical friendship in the field of education.

What to look up for before asking someone to be your critical friend

Selecting the right person to be your critical friend in education is a crucial step in ensuring a productive and mutually beneficial relationship. Before approaching someone to fulfill this role, consider the following factors:

Professional Expertise: Look for someone with relevant expertise and experience in the field of education or in the specific area where you seek improvement. Their knowledge should align with your needs and goals.

Compatibility: Consider whether you share common values, educational philosophies, or teaching styles. Compatibility can make it easier to work together and ensure your critical friend understands your perspective.

Trustworthiness: Ensure that the person you choose is trustworthy and can be relied upon to maintain confidentiality. You should feel comfortable sharing your challenges and concerns openly with them.

Communication Skills: Look for someone with strong communication skills, including active listening, empathetic understanding, and the ability to provide constructive feedback in a respectful manner.

Availability: Consider whether the person has the time and availability to commit to regular meetings and discussions. Availability is crucial for maintaining a consistent and supportive relationship.

Track Record: Explore their track record as a teacher or mentor. Have they previously served as a critical friend or mentor to others, and what were the outcomes of those relationships?

Willingness to Help: Ensure that the person is willing and motivated to take on the role of a critical friend. They should be genuinely interested in supporting your growth and improvement.

Alignment of Goals: Confirm that your goals and objectives align with the potential critical friend’s willingness and ability to assist you in achieving those goals.

Respectful and Non-Judgmental Attitude: Seek someone who can provide critical feedback without being judgmental or overly critical. A respectful and non-judgmental attitude is essential for a positive working relationship.

Conflict Resolution Skills: Assess their ability to handle conflicts or disagreements in a constructive and respectful manner. Conflicts may arise during the critical friendship, and the person should be equipped to address them effectively.

Personal Chemistry: While not mandatory, having a positive personal rapport or chemistry with your critical friend can make the relationship more enjoyable and productive.

Mutual Benefit: Consider how the potential critical friend might benefit from the relationship. It should be a mutually beneficial arrangement where both parties can learn and grow.

Long-Term Commitment: Determine whether the person is willing to commit to the long-term nature of a critical friendship, as this is not typically a short-term arrangement.

References: If possible, seek references or recommendations from others who have worked with the potential critical friend in a similar capacity. This can provide insights into their effectiveness and professionalism.

Clear Expectations: Once you’ve identified a potential critical friend, discuss and establish clear expectations regarding the frequency of meetings, the nature of feedback, and the goals of the relationship.

Remember that selecting the right critical friend is a crucial step in your professional development. Take your time to find someone who aligns with your needs and goals, and don’t hesitate to have open and honest discussions about the expectations and parameters of the relationship before formally inviting them to be your critical friend.



PLC Topics for Teachers in Ghana and NTS

GES Professional Learning Community (PLC) Digital Platform manual – How to Register


Peter N. Djangmah is a multifaceted individual with a passion for education, entrepreneurship, and blogging. With a firm belief in the power of digital education and science, I am affectionately known as the Private Minister of Information. Connect with me
1 1 vote
Article Rating
Notify of

1 Comment
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Madam Rose
Madam Rose
September 2, 2023 6:50 pm

Waoo thank you.

Related Articles

Back to top button
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x

Adblock Detected

Kindly turn on ads to support our work